/** * https://gist.github.com/samthor/64b114e4a4f539915a95b91ffd340acc */ (function() { var check = document.createElement('script'); if (!('noModule' in check) && 'onbeforeload' in check) { var = false; document.addEventListener('beforeload', function(e) { if (e.target === check) { = true; } else if (!e.target.hasAttribute('nomodule') || !) { return; } e.preventDefault(); }, true); check.type = 'module'; check.src = '.'; document.head.appendChild(check); check.remove(); } }());

Summary

  • The accused, Australian woman Erin Patterson, is being cross-examined by the prosecution in a triple-murder trial

  • Three people died after eating a beef Wellington lunch at Ms Patterson's house, while another became ill, but survived

  • The prosecution says Ms Patterson deliberately included poisonous mushrooms in a meal she served to guests – she denies this and her defence team says it was a "terrible accident"

  • The prosecution showed Ms Patterson a photo from her phone, suggesting it showed her calculating a lethal dose of death cap mushrooms, which Ms Patterson denied

  • Ms Patterson was also asked why in the days after the lunch she repeatedly lied to police about owning a food dehydrator, and said it was a "stupid knee-jerk reaction"

  • Ms Patterson denied telling her lunch guests she had cancer, contradicting evidence from Ian Wilkinson, who survived the lunch

Media caption,

Watch: Three things you need to know about Australia's mushroom murder trial

  1. Ms Patterson its foraging before fatal lunchpublished at 03:58 British Summer Time 5 June

    Lana Lam
    Live reporter

    Prosecutor Nanette Rogers now asks Ms Patterson if she foraged for wild mushrooms between 28 April - the day she purchased the food dehydrator - and the day of the lunch, 29 July.

    "Yes, I did do that," she replies saying they came from her own property, from the botanic gardens at Korumburra, and from a nearby rail trail.

    Ms Patterson is then asked if she lied about adding wild mushrooms into the beef Wellington, to which she says no.

    She has previously said wild mushrooms may have been stored in the same container as ones she had bought, and unintentionally ended up in the dish that way.

  2. Accused its lie about foraging was 'deliberate'published at 03:49 British Summer Time 5 June

    The prosecutor moves on to the lie Ms Patterson told about foraging for mushrooms – she denied ever having done that, in a police interview on 5 August.

    "I suggest this was a deliberate lie by you. It wasn’t a mistaken lie," Dr Rogers says.

    "It was a lie, yes," Ms Patterson responds.

  3. Prosecution asks if Ms Patterson indended to serve death caps to husbandpublished at 03:47 British Summer Time 5 June

    Simon Atkinson
    reporting from Morwell

    The trial has heard Ms Patterson estranged husband Simon Patterson declined to come to the lunch at the last minute.

    Now he has come up in the cross examination for the first time.

    “I suggest that you had been dehydrating death cap mushrooms... for the purpose of putting in the beef Wellington you served up to the guests at the lunch,” says Nanette Rogers.

    ”And further that you intended to serve one of those beef Wellingtons to Simon Patterson.”

    "If he had come I would have given him a beef Wellington too," Ms Patterson says. “But not one with death cap mushrooms in it, intentionally."

  4. 'You were calculating fatal dose', prosecutor allegespublished at 03:38 British Summer Time 5 June

    Katy Watson
    reporting from Morwell

    On that same photo showing mushrooms on a set of kitchen scales - which the prosecution proposes were death caps - Dr Rogers says: "I suggest that you were weighing these mushrooms so that you could calculate the weight required for... a fatal dose."

    Ms Patterson disagrees.

  5. We’re back from a short breakpublished at 03:34 British Summer Time 5 June

    James Chater
    Live reporter

    Before the break, the prosecution was asking about photos of mushrooms on Ms Patterson’s phone, with prosecutor Nanette Rogers suggesting one showed death cap mushrooms she had foraged.

    Dr Rogers launches back into questioning, suggesting that Ms Patterson saw a post on iNaturalist - a website for logging plant and animal sightings - about death cap mushrooms on 18 April 2023.

    Ms Patterson disagrees.

    The prosecution then suggests that she went to the town where they were spotted, called Loch, ten days later.

    Ms Patterson hesitates, saying she doesn't know if she went to the town that day, then denying she went there to find death cap mushrooms.

  6. Judge says trial will go beyond six weekspublished at 03:18 British Summer Time 5 June

    How much time is left in this trial? Judge Christopher Beale has just set out a rough timeline for the 14-member jury – who were expecting the trial to last around six weeks.

    But this is already week six, and he warns them there's still a way to go.

    "I’m not going to put a figure on how much time is left to run in this trial but let me just summarise for you," he says.

    He says Ms Patterson will most likely be in the witness box until early next week, followed by a few days of legal discussion and the possibility of "more evidence".

    The prosecution and defence will give their closing addresses and then Justice Beale said he'll deliver final directions which "takes quite a bit of time".

    Then the jury will deliberate and he says he can't put an exact date on this.

    "How long is a piece of string," he says, reminding the jury they should "take all the time you need".

    He jokes that next week is a shorter one as there's a public holiday on Monday - "some good news", with the jury erupting in laughter at the comment.

    And with that he sends them out for a break and a cup of tea, to more laughter.

  7. More intense questioning – and brief pause for teapublished at 03:11 British Summer Time 5 June

    James Chater
    Live reporter

    Just as we were getting to some more pointed questions from the prosecutor about photos on Ms Patterson's phone, showing mushrooms on a set of kitchen scales, the judge suggests a brief break for morning tea.

    The prosecution had suggested the picture taken by Ms Patterson showed death cap mushrooms foraged on or after 28 April 2023.

    Ms Patterson responded saying, "No that's not correct."

  8. Court hears about accused hiding mushrooms in foodpublished at 03:00 British Summer Time 5 June

    Simon Atkinson
    reporting from Morwell

    The prosecution turns to Erin Patterson’s online posts about hiding mushrooms in food to feed to her kids.

    "I suggest you were testing if you could hide mushrooms in people’s food within them noticing. Correct">"I was trying to get extra vegetables into my kids' bodies."

  9. Dramatic exchange over dehydratorpublished at 02:58 British Summer Time 5 June

    Katy Watson
    reporting from Morwell

    The cross-examination of Erin Patterson has been fast from the start and that exchange over her use of death cap mushrooms in the dehydrator was dramatic.

    Prosecutor Nanette Rogers fired a long list of questions at the defendant and Ms Patterson batted them all away with a firm "no", denying that she ever knowingly prepared death cap mushrooms.

    Erin Patterson, who was emotional a few minutes ago, answered clearly during that exchange – consistently rejecting an intention to kill her relatives.

  10. 'You rushed to get rid of evidence,' prosecutor sayspublished at 02:51 British Summer Time 5 June

    James Chater
    Live reporter

    "You had been using it to dehydrate mushrooms. And not just any old mushrooms - death cap mushrooms correct">"No."

  11. Several questions about the food dehydratorpublished at 02:46 British Summer Time 5 June

    The first line of questioning centres on discussions Erin Patterson had about buying a food dehydrator.

    Dr Rogers recounts evidence from a friend of Ms Patterson who said the accused was “a bit excited”.

    Patterson is then shown the invoice for the appliance, bought on 28 April – which is almost exactly three months before the lunch.

    “You took it home… and subsequently used it">Now we are seeing once again the CCTV footage of Ms Patterson at the local tip on August 2. We see her red car pulling in and Ms Patterson walking out with a large box - the dehydrator.

  12. Prosecutor begins her cross-examinationpublished at 02:40 British Summer Time 5 June

    Simon Atkinson
    reporting from Morwell

    And the defence is done.

    Seconds after - no pause for breath - prosecutor Nanette Rogers is on her feet and out of the starting blocks, beginning her cross examination.

    She picks up where Mr Mandy left off, jumping straight to lies Ms Patterson told police.

  13. Ms Patterson denies intentionally killing relativespublished at 02:38 British Summer Time 5 June

    Lana Lam
    Live reporter

    Ms Patterson is now asked by her defence lawyer if she intended to kill or cause serious injury to Donald Patterson - her father-in-law - by serving the beef Wellington meal?

    "No, I didn't," she replies.

    Did you intend to harm him in any way?

    "No," Ms Patterson says.

    Colin Mandy SC then in quick succession asks the same two questions about Gail Patterson, Heather Wilkinson and Ian Wilkinson.

    To each question, Ms Patterson answers "no" before breaking down in tears.

  14. Lawyer quizzes her over more liespublished at 02:31 British Summer Time 5 June

    Tiffanie Turnbull
    Live editor

    Ms Patterson also told police she'd never foraged mushrooms - a lie told for the same reason as the others, she explains: she was scared of being blamed.

    Mr Mandy is now running through a series of questions, rapid fire.

    All of the beef Wellingtons were the same, Ms Patterson answers him. She did not lie about buying dried mushrooms from an Asian grocer, she says to another query.

    "Did you pretend to be sick following the lunch">"No."

    Return to the latest post
  15. Erin Patterson questioned over repeated lies about food dehydratorpublished at 02:21 British Summer Time 5 June

    Simon Atkinson
    Reporting from Morwell

    Erin Patterson is asked by her barrister, Colin Mandy, why in the days after the lunch she repeatedly lied to police about owning a food dehydrator.

    She says by this point she was concerned the meals she had prepared was responsible for making people sick.

    “It was this stupid knee-jerk reaction to dig deeper and keep lying. I was just scared, but I shouldn’t have done it.”

  16. And we're underwaypublished at 02:10 British Summer Time 5 June

    Court has started for the day, and Ms Patterson's barrister Colin Mandy has jumped straight back into questioning her.

    He's asking her about her use of her phone while police searched her house on 5 August 2023, days after the fatal lunch she'd hosted.

  17. A quick geography lessonpublished at 01:58 British Summer Time 5 June

    The case is being heard in Latrobe Valley Law Courts - a fairly small building on the main road through the town of Morwell in regional Victoria.

    It is about a 45-minute drive from the Leongatha home, where the lunch took place.

    Both towns are about a two hours from Melbourne.

    The judge, barristers and some of the court staff are travelling here each week and staying nearby (accommodation had been hard to find!). Court finishes at lunchtime on Fridays - in part to allow out-of-towners to get home for the weekend.

    Jurors however have been drawn from the local area.

    Map showing Melbourne, Morwell and Leongatha
  18. Power outage causing slight delayspublished at 01:50 British Summer Time 5 June

    As well as delaying caffeine intake for our poor reporters, the power outage in Morwell has delayed the start of proceedings a little this morning.

    We're expecting the court to reconvene very shortly though.

  19. Who are the key players in the courtroom?published at 01:41 British Summer Time 5 June

    Erin Patterson's triple murder trial started on 29 April and is into its sixth week now.

    Let's take a quick look at the key legal players in a case that has captured huge global attention.

    The Judge

    Justice Christopher Beale is presiding over the trial

    For the prosecution

    Representing the crown's case is prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC

    For the defence

    Erin Patterson's defence is being led by Colin Mandy SC

  20. Hello from Morwellpublished at 01:32 British Summer Time 5 June

    Simon Atkinson
    reporting from Morwell

    Good morning form chilly Morwell where the big news in town so far today has been a power cut.

    Traffic lights were out, the local supermarket was plunged into darkness and the local cafes were unable to make their flat whites - leaving lawyers and journalists a little cranky.

    But it’s back on now, court is operating and Erin Patterson will be in the witness box any minute to face some more questions form her barrister before the prosecution can opt to cross-examine her.